A Playbook for Major Donor Retention and Connection
Scaling Major Gifts. Strategies, action steps, and ideas for scaling major gifts by Tammy Zonker, Major Gift Expert & Keynote Speaker.
The true measure of fundraising success isn’t landing the first major gift—it’s turning that milestone into years of partnership and impact. In my experience, donor retention is where the real transformation happens, yet it’s often overlooked by busy teams focused on acquisition. In this edition of Scaling Major Gifts, I want to talk candidly about why donor retention matters and lay out proven steps any nonprofit leader can take to nurture lasting relationships.
Why Major Donor Retention Is Mission-Critical
As someone who's spent nearly three decades raising major gifts, I can tell you firsthand: getting that first big check is a thrill, but it’s just the starting line. Retaining major donors doesn’t simply benefit your bottom line—it transforms how you sustain and scale your mission. Acquiring a new major donor costs five to ten times more than retaining an existing one, and repeat donors bring more than money—they champion causes, open doors, and become powerful advocates for your organization.
Recent numbers drive this home. Donor retention rates hover around 45%, but jump to over 60% for repeat donors in the major gift space. Retained donors are your perennial garden—they endure because relationships flourish, not just transactions.
Common Barriers: Pain Points I See Every Day
Let’s face it, retention hurdles aren’t unique to big shops. Whether in a national organization or a one-person operation, I regularly see these stumbling blocks:
Transactional Relationships: Gifts treated as single events, not the beginning of a journey
Lack of Personalization: Generic thank-yous ignore individual donor motivation and interests
Inconsistent Stewardship: Stewardship falls off the to-do list when things get hectic
Limited Data Tracking: If you’re stuck in spreadsheets or have gaps in donor records, critical details and connections get lost
These obstacles are real—but absolutely conquerable.
Four Cornerstones of Donor Retention
Here’s the framework I use and teach:
1. Build a Culture of Gratitude
Gratitude shouldn’t just be perfunctory—make it prompt, heartfelt, and specific. In my experience, asking board members to call or write personalized notes multiplies the impact. This not only makes donors feel valued, it pulls board members closer to your mission.
2. Personalize the Journey
Donors are not ATMs—they’re individuals. One approach I’ve seen work well is segmenting donors by history, interests, or giving level using a CRM, then sending tailored communications: birthday cards, news about their favorite programs, or even sharing a great book or recipe if it suits their passions.
3. Report Back with Impact
Regular, meaningful updates are your watering can. Donors want concrete evidence of their “return”—not just numbers, but stories, photos, and authentic video messages. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project shows that donors who receive impactful updates are 40% more likely to give again.
4. Create Opportunities for Deeper Engagement
Donors who are invited to campaign committees, volunteer roles, strategy sessions, or exclusive events become true partners. I encourage creating giving societies and inviting donors into conversations that let them help steer the mission.
IRL: Transforming a Single Gift into a Ripple Effect
A few years ago, I worked with an organization that landed a first-time major gift from a donor we barely knew. Instead of sending a generic thank-you, we invited her for a personalized tour, introduced her to staff and beneficiaries, and followed up with a video message tailored to her interests. Next year—not only did she renew at a higher level, she brought two new major philanthropists into our orbit. Stewardship wasn’t just a task; it was an experience, and it paid exponential dividends.
Another organization I coached implemented annual impact books filled with photos and letters for their top donors. Their major donor retention rate soared to 71%—the donors felt like one of the heroes, not just check writers.
Tools and Resources to Streamline Stewardship
Here are some products I recommend from firsthand use and sector benchmarking:
CRM systems: DonorPerfect, Virtuous, and Neon CRM
Personalized video platforms: ThankView and BombBomb—for sending heartfelt, branded stewardship messages
Prospect research tools: DonorSearch, Kindsight
These solutions help manage data, automate tasks, segment audiences, and deliver communications that make stewardship manageable—even for lean teams.
Action Steps: What You Can Do This Month
Want to see immediate momentum? Here are six steps you can put into practice right away:
Audit your current stewardship. Where are gaps? Where can you personalize?
Audit your current stewardship. Where are gaps? Where can you personalize?
Segment major donors—board members, first-timers, multi-year givers—and tailor outreach
Schedule quarterly impact updates; share stories and photos, not just numbers
Get your board involved—calls and notes have outsized impact
Invest in a CRM to centralize donor data and track every interaction
Track, evaluate, refine—use stewardship matrices and review quarterly, asking for donor feedback
Try just one new approach this month and watch how even small changes transform relationships.
Equal Parts Art, Science, and Adventure.
Having walked this road for nearly 30 years, I know fundraising is equal parts art, science, and adventure. Each donor relationship is a chapter in your organization’s story. The question isn’t just, "Did they give?" but "How can we help them feel like one of the heroes?" The most successful fundraisers build trust, connect authentically, and celebrate every milestone.
I encourage you to share your wins and lessons—what made your stewardship unforgettable? What challenges are you facing? Email me your thoughts or tag me on LinkedIn; I’ll feature inspiring stories in upcoming podcasts and newsletters.
Major gift retention isn’t magic—it’s meticulous, intentional stewardship. Let’s build lasting legacies, one thoughtful touch at a time.
Keep scaling,
Tammy Zonker
Author, Major Gift Expert & Keynote Speaker
President, Fundraising Transformed
President, Modern Institute for Charitable Giving
ps – Please share this ❤️
Master major donor prospecting, digital engagement strategies, and making confident and authentic asks.
Donors not returning your calls? Pipeline getting thinner? Uncomfortable making big asks? Feeling the pressure to hit bigger goals, faster?
Join us at the upcoming Excellence in Major Gift Fundraising Seminar—October 13–15, 2025, and get three dynamic days of high-impact training from the sector’s best major gift fundraising faculty to help you transform your approach—and your results!
This certified program has been one of the sector’s most reputable major gift fundraising seminars for 34 years. Trusted by 12,000+ alumni. Seating is limited, and early registration is underway—secure your spot today!